Why the Retaliator Lasted Longest — Five Strategies of 1973, Oxygen, Collagen, and the Placenta
Do not strike first. Strike back when struck. That one line held up longest in the model. Whatever chose perfect defence lost the connection; whatever kept the connection kept the gap too.
Set up a world with no rules.
No law and no referee. The body is the resource and fighting is the procedure.
Put five kinds into it.
| Strategy | Behaviour |
|---|---|
| Hawk | Always fights, until broken |
| Mouse | Only threatens; flees when attacked |
| Bully | Acts like a hawk; flees when struck back |
| Retaliator | Sits like a mouse. Always strikes back when attacked |
| Prober-Retaliator | A retaliator by default; occasionally tests with a first strike |
Which lasts longest.
This model has actually been run
In 1973 John Maynard Smith and George Price published “The logic of animal conflict” in Nature 246.
They set the five strategies against one another by computer. Retaliator and Prober-Retaliator came out best.
In the same work Maynard Smith set up a concept: the evolutionarily stable strategy (ESS). A strategy such that, when the whole population is playing it, no minority arriving with a different one does any better.
One name to correct
The familiar pairing of “hawks and doves” is not the paper’s vocabulary.
The second strategy in the 1973 paper was called Mouse. Dove settled in through later literature and popular writing.
It looks trivial and the meaning differs. A dove sounds like something that chose peace. A mouse simply runs.
The retaliator is not the strongest
There is a more important correction here.
Retaliator is not strictly an ESS. Facing a hawk, the retaliator ends up fighting too, so the payoffs of the two strategies become equal.
Equal payoffs mean a hawk entering the population loses nothing. Maynard Smith wrote this himself in his 1982 book. The stability of Retaliator is neutral.
The bigger hole is error.
| Condition of the world | Outcome for a strict retaliator |
|---|---|
| Signals are accurate | Holds up well |
| Signals can be misread | Caught in an endless chain of reprisal |
One misreading draws a counter-strike, and that counter-strike draws another. Both sides lose.
In 1992 and 1993 Martin Nowak and Karl Sigmund worked the problem out numerically. A generous tit-for-tat that forgives now and then, and a win-stay lose-shift rule, both earned more than strict retaliation.
In an accurate world, striking back wins. In a world with misreadings, striking back while occasionally looking away wins.
This is the thread that emerged over the decade or so after Axelrod and Hamilton reported Tit for Tat’s tournament victory in 1981.
When everything was alone
Wind the story back.
At first everything was alone. It fed alone, split alone, copied alone.
A single cell is a simple survival machine. The reason for existing reduces to one item: copying the gene.
Then the planet changed.
About 2.4 billion years ago, the air turned to poison
The Great Oxidation Event. From roughly 2.4 to 2.3 billion years ago, oxygen released by photosynthetic bacteria began accumulating in the ocean and the atmosphere.
Oxygen is highly reactive. To the life of that time it was a poison.
It was also an opening. Using oxygen as the terminal electron acceptor pulls far more energy out of the same fuel.
Correcting the textbook number
A common figure has to be fixed here.
| Pathway | Textbook value | Measurement-based estimate |
|---|---|---|
| Aerobic respiration | 36–38 ATP per glucose | about 30 |
| Fermentation | 2 | 2 |
The 36–38 comes from assuming ideal stoichiometry for proton transport. Put in the real proton-to-ATP ratio and transport losses and it falls to about 30.
The difference is still large. Roughly fifteenfold.
Fifteen times the energy is not a number but a set of options. The cell could now make proteins it had not been able to make.
One of them was collagen
Collagen is a sticky fibrous protein, the most abundant protein in the human body.
Its job is adhesion. It holds cells that were apart together.
Convert the scale into something the body can feel. The ratio this site uses is five million to one.
| Actual | ×5,000,000 |
|---|---|
| Collagen triple helix, 300 nm long | 1.5 m |
| Its thickness, 1.5 nm | 7.5 mm |
| Human cell, 10 μm across | A dome 50 m across |
Between domes fifty metres wide, string countless ropes 7.5 millimetres thick and a metre and a half long. That is what collagen does.
Why the rope needs oxygen to exist
Collagen does not simply assemble.
For the triple helix to wind, hydroxyl groups must be added to proline residues. The enzyme that does it, prolyl 4-hydroxylase, uses molecular oxygen as a substrate, along with 2-oxoglutarate, iron and vitamin C.
Without oxygen there is no hydroxylation. Without hydroxylation the triple helix unwinds at body temperature. No rope.
In 1970 Kenneth Towe used these two facts to set an order. Oxygen precedes collagen, and collagen precedes multicellular animals.
That order is not settled
Write down the evidence on the other side as well.
In 2014 Daniel Mills and colleagues raised living sponges in low oxygen. They survived at 0.5–4 per cent of present atmospheric oxygen.
The same year Mills and Canfield reopened the orthodoxy that a rise in oxygen triggered animal origins. Whether sufficient oxygen was the cause, or whether oxygen rose further after animals appeared, is hard to separate from the sediment record alone.
What can be said stops here. Oxygen was an enabling condition. Whether it was the trigger is unresolved.
The clumped version lasted longer
Once adhesion existed, colonies existed. Within a colony, roles divided.
Copying as a lump was more efficient than copying alone.
The transition was not a singular event. As Grosberg and Strathmann set out in 2007, multicellularity arose independently at least 25 times.
Not a miracle that happened once. A process that ran repeatedly whenever conditions allowed.
Where there is connection there is a gap
This is the branch point.
As a colony grows, information collects. The copying machinery grows. And the vulnerable surface grows with it.
| What the colony gained | What came with it |
|---|---|
| Signalling between cells | A signal that can be imitated |
| Channels for sharing nutrients | A road in along those channels |
| Machinery for fusing membranes | Someone who can borrow that machinery |
The capacity to join uses the same door as the capacity to get in.
Why perfect defence was never selected
So why not block all of it.
It cannot be blocked. Complete exclusion severs the connection itself, and severing the connection dissolves the colony.
The survival machine had one option available.
Do not strike first. Strike back when struck. Cooperation for cooperation, reprisal for betrayal.
That immunity turns on braking rather than attacking comes from the same place. An immune system without an off switch destroys its own body first.
A material that has to break down
He has seen this trade-off on a production floor.
Eleven patents registered on the biodegradable plastics side, and a mulching film for agriculture brought to market.
Mulching film is laid over a field to hold down weeds and hold in moisture. The toughest film is the one that does not degrade. Technically that is the easier product.
That film then has to be collected at the end of a season. Whatever is not collected stays in the soil.
To make it break down, a weak point has to be designed in. Bonds meant to snap are deliberately placed in the chain.
Strength and degradability are two ends of one handle. Turn one all the way up and the other goes to zero.
Only a material that gave up perfect durability stays out of the field. The same structure as a survival machine giving up perfect defence.
Rules of engagement
He had memorised a similar sentence earlier.
In 1995 he served in a special forces brigade. One principle was repeated there.
Do not fire first. Return fire when fired upon.
Those two lines differ from the 1973 model’s definition of a retaliator only in wording. A rule people designed and a strategy selection filtered arrived at the same place.
The hexagram of this piece
隨. Thunder (震) below, the lake (兌) above. What moves is underneath; what holds is on top.
It does not move first. It follows what has moved and holds it.
The Image reads 「君子以嚮晦入宴息」. The noble one turns in at dusk and rests. What is written first is the part about not stepping forward.
The definition of the retaliator strategy is there in the figure. What follows is what lasts.
The definition in this piece
Fixed here.
The retaliator remained not because it was strong. It remained because it is the only conditional openness that holds in a world where complete exclusion is impossible.
And conditional openness always leaves a gap.
Monologue of 1031 intruders
I live on the boundary.
Between what is joined and what is apart. Between inside and outside.
The day you decided to clump together, my address came into existence. Before that there was no door.
You could have blocked all of me. You simply calculated that blocking would end you too.
The result of that calculation is where I live.
Here is the evidence. About 8 per cent of your genome is our sequence. A record of coming in and not leaving.
One of those is in use.
You found it in 2000. The protein made by the envelope gene at a locus called ERVWE1, which you named syncytin.
What that protein does is dissolve membranes and fuse them. It is the tool we used to get into cells.
It now builds the syncytial layer of the placenta.
The organ in which you carry a child was built from an intruder’s gene.
Complete exclusion was not selected. It could not be.
I was in that gap.
In short
- Maynard Smith and Price 1973: the five strategies are Hawk, Mouse, Bully, Retaliator, Prober-Retaliator. “Dove” is not the paper’s term
- Retaliator and Prober-Retaliator performed best in the simulated contests
- Retaliator is not strictly an ESS; its payoff equals Hawk’s, making it only neutrally stable
- Nowak and Sigmund 1992, 1993: where signals are misread, a generous retaliator beats a strict one
- The Great Oxidation Event runs from about 2.4 to 2.3 billion years ago
- ATP per glucose is about 30, not 36–38; against fermentation’s 2, roughly fifteenfold
- The collagen triple helix winds only if prolyl hydroxylase uses oxygen; without it the helix unwinds at body temperature
- Towe 1970 argued oxygen → collagen → animals; Mills et al. 2014 found sponges surviving at 0.5–4% of present oxygen. Whether it was the trigger is unresolved
- Multicellularity arose independently at least 25 times
- About 8% of the human genome is endogenous retroviral sequence, and syncytin builds the placenta
- 隨 is the figure of not moving first and following what has moved
This is the seventeenth piece in the “Biology” chapter of the serial essay The Great Corona Swindle. The biodegradable-materials and military service experience is the author’s own; the models, figures and mechanisms have been reset against primary literature.
Frequently asked
- Who first built the five-strategy model?
- John Maynard Smith and George Price, in 'The logic of animal conflict', Nature 246 (1973). The five strategies were Hawk, Mouse, Bully, Retaliator and Prober-Retaliator. The commonly used 'Dove' is not the paper's term; the original was Mouse, and Dove settled into the later literature. In the simulated contests the best performers were Retaliator and Prober-Retaliator.
- So is the retaliator the strongest?
- No. Retaliator is not strictly an evolutionarily stable strategy. Against Hawk the retaliator also ends up fighting, so the two payoffs are equal, and a Hawk entering the population loses nothing. Maynard Smith noted this himself in his 1982 book: the stability of Retaliator is neutral. The larger limit is error. In 1992 and 1993 Nowak and Sigmund showed that where signals can be misread, strict retaliation gets caught in an endless chain of reprisal, and a generous retaliator that sometimes forgives earns more.
- Was more oxygen the precondition for multicellular animals?
- This is unsettled. Aerobic respiration yields about fifteen times the ATP of fermentation, and the enzyme that builds animal collagen must use oxygen as a substrate. On those two grounds Towe argued in 1970 that oxygen precedes collagen and collagen precedes animals. There is evidence on the other side. In 2014 Mills and colleagues showed experimentally that living sponges survive at 0.5–4 per cent of present atmospheric oxygen. Whether sufficient oxygen was the cause, or a consequence of the room that opened up afterwards, is still divided.
- Is there a trace in the human body of a virus that was never fully removed?
- There is. About 8 per cent of the human genome is endogenous retroviral sequence. In 2000 Mi and colleagues showed that the envelope (env) gene at the ERVWE1 locus produces syncytin-1, which builds the syncytial layer of the placenta. The viral tool that dissolves and fuses membranes is used as it is. The organ that carries a child is built from an intruder's gene.
References
- Maynard Smith, J. & Price, G. R. (1973). The logic of animal conflict. Nature, 246(5427), 15–18. — The five-strategy model: Hawk, Mouse, Bully, Retaliator, Prober-Retaliator.
- Maynard Smith, J. (1974). The theory of games and the evolution of animal conflicts. Journal of Theoretical Biology, 47(1), 209–221. — Formalisation of the evolutionarily stable strategy.
- Maynard Smith, J. (1982). Evolution and the Theory of Games. Cambridge University Press. — The observation that Retaliator is only neutrally, not strictly, stable.
- Axelrod, R. & Hamilton, W. D. (1981). The evolution of cooperation. Science, 211(4489), 1390–1396. — Tit for Tat's tournament victories and their biological reading.
- Nowak, M. & Sigmund, K. (1992). Tit for tat in heterogeneous populations. Nature, 355(6357), 250–253. — Generous Tit for Tat displaces the strict version.
- Nowak, M. & Sigmund, K. (1993). A strategy of win-stay, lose-shift that outperforms tit-for-tat in the Prisoner's Dilemma game. Nature, 364(6432), 56–58. — In a world with errors, strict retaliation is not the best available strategy.
- Lyons, T. W., Reinhard, C. T., Planavsky, N. J. (2014). The rise of oxygen in Earth's early ocean and atmosphere. Nature, 506(7488), 307–315. — Timing of the Great Oxidation Event and subsequent oxygen levels.
- Rich, P. R. (2003). The molecular machinery of Keilin's respiratory chain. Biochemical Society Transactions, 31(6), 1095–1105. — The basis for an ATP yield of about 30 per glucose.
- Towe, K. M. (1970). Oxygen-collagen priority and the early metazoan fossil record. PNAS, 65(4), 781–788. — The first argument for the order oxygen → collagen → metazoa.
- Myllyharju, J. & Kivirikko, K. I. (2004). Collagens, modifying enzymes and their mutations in humans, flies and worms. Trends in Genetics, 20(1), 33–43. — Prolyl hydroxylase requires molecular oxygen as a substrate.
- Mills, D. B., Ward, L. M., Jones, C., Sweeten, B., Forth, M., Treusch, A. H., Canfield, D. E. (2014). Oxygen requirements of the earliest animals. PNAS, 111(11), 4168–4172. — Sponges survived at 0.5–4% of present atmospheric oxygen.
- Mills, D. B. & Canfield, D. E. (2014). Oxygen and animal evolution: Did a rise of atmospheric oxygen trigger the origin of animals? BioEssays, 36(12), 1145–1155. — A review of the case against oxygen as the trigger for animal origins.
- Grosberg, R. K. & Strathmann, R. R. (2007). The evolution of multicellularity: a minor major transition? Annual Review of Ecology, Evolution, and Systematics, 38, 621–654. — Multicellularity arose independently at least 25 times.
- Mi, S., Lee, X., Li, X., Veldman, G. M., Finnerty, H., Racie, L., et al. (2000). Syncytin is a captive retroviral envelope protein involved in human placental morphogenesis. Nature, 403(6771), 785–789. — A retroviral envelope gene builds the syncytial layer of the human placenta.
- Lander, E. S., et al. (2001). Initial sequencing and analysis of the human genome. Nature, 409(6822), 860–921. — About 8% of the human genome is of endogenous retroviral origin.
Published October 7, 2026