Biology EP. 18 / 64 By SENSMAN

Syncytin — The Enemy Built Us, and Did It More Than Once

The technique for dissolving one membrane into another was built for getting in. That technique became the placenta — not once, but separately in lineage after lineage, from different viruses.

Syncytin — where two cell membranes dissolve into a single multinucleate layer

Did our ancestor come out of an egg.

The founding myths say so. Hyeokgeose, Jumong, Seok Talhae — each born from an egg.

An egg is a closed world. It completes itself inside a shell and does not mix with what is outside.

We arrived another way.

Half of a foetus is another person

Half the genes come from the father’s side. To the immune system that half is someone else’s tissue.

In transplantation a half-match still provokes rejection. Inside a uterus, no attack comes for nine months.

In 1953 Peter Medawar put the problem formally on the table. The immunological paradox of pregnancy.

The answer found since is not one thing.

LayerWhat it does
SyncytiotrophoblastNo boundaries between cells, so little for an immune cell to get between
MHC class I suppressionClassical molecules are barely displayed
HLA-GA non-classical molecule that holds natural killer cells back
Uterine immune conversionThe character of the local immune cells changes during pregnancy

How much each contributes is unsettled. The first line, though, is clear. Being one layer with no boundaries is itself part of the defence.

How is that layer built.

Why there has to be more than one nucleus

The rule of one nucleus per cell has exceptions, and the places where they occur have a family resemblance.

TissueWhy it fuses
Skeletal muscleExplosive force needs protein in bulk. One nucleus is too slow
OsteoclastDissolving bone needs heavy machinery spread wide
SyncytiotrophoblastConstant exchange with the mother — and no gaps

The common factor is throughput. There is a ceiling on what a single nucleus can produce. The way past that ceiling was to erase the boundaries.

The difficulty is that membranes do not join easily.

A membrane is a boundary. Join it carelessly and the contents spill. Making two into one means dissolving the outer lipid leaflets together and then joining the inner ones. That takes dedicated machinery.

Convert the scale into something the body can feel. The ratio is five million to one.

Actual×5,000,000
Cell membrane, 4 nm thick2 cm
Human cell, 10 μm acrossA dome 50 m across

Two domes fifty metres wide stand touching, each walled in two centimetres of material. Melt those four walls together into one space without rupturing either. That is what a fusogen does.

One thing has to be made clear here

Writing that every boundary-dissolving technique came from an intruder is wrong.

TissueFusion machineryOrigin
Skeletal muscleMyomaker, myomergerThe host’s own genes
OsteoclastDC-STAMP, OC-STAMPThe host’s own genes
SyncytiotrophoblastSyncytin-1, syncytin-2Captured from retroviruses

Douglas Millay’s group found myomaker in 2013 and Bi’s group found myomerger in 2017. Both are genes mice and humans already carried. Not viral.

A curious detail attaches here. In 2014 Pérez-Vargas and colleagues solved the structure of EFF-1, a fusion protein of the nematode C. elegans, and found it has the same fold as viral class II fusogens.

Whether that is descent from a common ancestor, or separate arrival at the only shape that does the job, has not been settled.

What is confirmed as viral in origin is the placental side. That line does not wobble.

The capture did not happen once

This is the centre of today’s piece.

Human syncytin-1 comes from the ERVW-1 locus covered yesterday. But humans have a second. Blaise and colleagues found syncytin-2 in 2003, from a different retrovirus.

Look at other animals and it gets plainer.

LineageSyncytinSource virus
Human and apesSyncytin-1, syncytin-2Two different ones
MouseSyncytin-A, syncytin-BA lineage unrelated to the human one
Rabbits and haresOry1Another lineage again
Carnivores (dog, cat)Car1Another lineage again
Ruminants (cattle, sheep)Rum1Another lineage again

The source differs by lineage. One ancestor did not acquire it once and pass it down.

The placenta did not come from a single accident. The same process ran separately in lineage after lineage.

After the mammals split, each line fished a fusion gene out of whatever retrovirus was infecting it in its own era.

The same solution was selected over and over in the same place. Not a repetition of chance — a repetition of conditions.

Delete it and you find out

Correlation is not enough. In 2009 Dupressoir and colleagues deleted the syncytin-A gene in mice.

The result was unambiguous. The placental fusion layer did not form. The exchange structure never stood, and the embryos died in utero.

That is where a captured viral gene was shown by genetics to be a part that cannot be missing.

The placenta is a gate, not a wall

One of the most frequent questions at a pharmacy counter was this.

Handing medicine to a pregnant customer, almost every time the same sentence comes back. “Does this reach the baby?”

The accurate answer sits between yes and no. The placenta is not a wall that blocks. It is a gate that selects.

Property that decides transferTendency
Molecular weightSmaller crosses more readily; below roughly 500 Da, most crosses
LipophilicityHigher crosses more readily
Plasma protein bindingHigher crosses less
IonisationIonised forms cross less

Active transporters and efflux pumps sit on top of that, and the placenta metabolises some drugs itself.

None of that table can be recited at a counter. The frame of the explanation was always the same, though. It is not a device that lets nothing through. It is a device in which what passes has been decided.

Antibodies are handed across actively. Oxygen and nutrients are sent. Waste is collected. And immune attack is held down.

A structure that is selectively open. Had it been fully closed, the foetus would starve.

The hexagram of this piece

蠱. Wind (巽) below, mountain (艮) above. Blocked by the mountain, the wind cannot circulate and stagnates inside.

The character makes it plainer: worms (蟲) inside a vessel (皿). Something from outside that has taken up residence within.

The judgement reads 「幹父之蠱」 — take on the work the father left behind.

The Image reads 「山下有風 蠱 君子以振民育德」. The noble one rouses the people and cultivates virtue.

What was inherited has a worm in it, and instead of discarding it, it is taken on and put to work. No figure comes closer to a retrovirus settled inside a genome.

The definition in this piece

Fixed here.

A protein built for invasion became a structure of reproduction. And that conversion was not one accident.

It was selected repeatedly — separately in each lineage, from different viruses. That it repeated means it was not chance but process.

Monologue of 1031 intruders

The technique for dissolving a membrane was built for getting in.

There was one purpose. Invasion. Breaking a boundary to push a gene through it.

That gene stayed, a very long time ago, inside the germ cells of your ancestors.

You did not delete it. You picked it up and used it.

What we ask is what came after. Was a membrane-dissolving tool really all we left behind.

The way of breaking a boundary. The way of taking in what is other. A structure that divides self from not-self without severing the two completely.

You are running all of it.

The egg is isolation. The placenta is coexistence. You were not born inside a closed world.

You came here through another person’s body.

Did you absorb us, or are we continuing in the form called you.

The same capture happened separately in mice, in rabbits, in dogs, in cattle. Once can be called an accident. Five times goes by another name.

The intruder did not disappear. It changed shape and is still inside you.

You have never made yourselves.

In short

  • Half a foetus’s genes are paternal, so half of it is another person to the immune system (Medawar 1953)
  • The syncytiotrophoblast is one layer without cell boundaries, barely displays classical MHC class I, and uses HLA-G to suppress attack; the relative contributions are unsettled
  • Muscle, osteoclasts and the syncytiotrophoblast are multinucleate for the same reason: throughput
  • Myomaker and myomerger in muscle and DC-STAMP in osteoclasts are the host’s own genes, not viral
  • Nematode EFF-1 shares the fold of viral class II fusogens; common ancestry versus convergence is unresolved
  • What is confirmed as viral in origin is placental syncytin
  • Capture repeated: twice in humans, twice in mice, separately in rabbits, carnivores and ruminants, each from a different virus
  • Deleting syncytin-A in mice prevents the fusion layer and kills the embryo (Dupressoir 2009)
  • The placenta is a gate, not a wall; weight, lipophilicity, protein binding and ionisation decide transfer
  • 蠱 is worms inside a vessel, and its judgement says to take on what was inherited

This is the eighteenth piece in the “Biology” chapter of the serial essay The Great Corona Swindle. The medication-counselling experience at a pharmacy counter is the author’s own; mechanisms and gene names have been reset against primary literature. Whether any particular drug may be used in pregnancy is outside the scope of this piece.

Frequently asked

Why is a foetus not attacked by the immune system?
In 1953 Peter Medawar formalised this as the immunological paradox of pregnancy. What has been found since is not a single answer but several layers. The syncytiotrophoblast in direct contact with maternal blood is one continuous layer with no boundaries between cells, leaving immune cells little to get between, and it displays almost no classical MHC class I. Instead it uses non-classical molecules such as HLA-G to hold natural killer cells back, and the character of the immune cells in the uterus itself changes during pregnancy. How much each layer contributes is not settled.
Does muscle fusion also come from a virus?
No, and this is where a common confusion arises. Myomaker and myomerger, used when skeletal muscle cells fuse, are the host's own genes. DC-STAMP, used when bone-dissolving osteoclasts fuse, is likewise a host gene. What has been confirmed as viral in origin is the syncytin on the placental side. There is a twist: some host fusion proteins, myomerger among them, share structural features with viral class II fusogens, and whether that reflects common ancestry or separate arrival at the same shape has not been settled.
How many times did syncytin capture occur?
Many. Human syncytin-1 and syncytin-2, mouse syncytin-A and syncytin-B, rabbit Ory1, carnivore Car1 and ruminant Rum1 were each captured separately, from different retroviruses. Different sources in different lineages means the placenta did not arise from one accident but from the same process running repeatedly.
What happens without syncytin?
In 2009 Dupressoir and colleagues deleted syncytin-A in mice. The placental fusion layer did not form and the embryos died in utero. It is the genetic confirmation that a captured viral gene is a required component of the reproductive structure.

References

#syncytin#syncytiotrophoblast#endogenous retrovirus#oviparity and viviparity#Medawar's paradox#myomaker#osteoclast fusion#independent capture#placental transfer#convergent evolution

#신시틴#융합영양막#내재성레트로바이러스#난생과태생#메다와의역설#마이오메이커#파골세포융합#독립포획#태반통과#수렴진화

Published October 8, 2026